Sidebar: Alt-Wheels Is Not Micromobility

I’ve been mean to Horace Dediu and his crew. Dediu coined “micromobility.” I called his lot “grifters” at least twice.

No one is twisting my arm to get me to say this: I apologize. Sincerely.

I was viewing things through my own lens. Which is Alt-Wheels.

And when I saw the micromobility people mentioning eScooters, I thought it natural for them to also encompass Alt-Wheels. And I got a bit heated when I saw they were not.

Basically, they have a different focus than mine. It’s larger.

Here is a chart from them that shows the upper weight boundary for what they classify as “micromobility.”

Their upper limit is a weight of 500 kilograms. That’s about 1,100 pounds!

That weight category would allow this to be classified as “micromobility”:

A car! Because it weighs “only 900 pounds” — or about 408 kilograms.

That is not what I see as “micro.” But Horace and his team do.

So it’s clear there’s very little overlap between our interests. Which means I will stop being mean to them for ignoring things they seem to consider “weightless.” And I apologize again.

But this is an opportunity for me to further clarify what I don’t mean and do mean by Alt-Wheels.

First, I’m kicking bicycles and eBikes out of the category. It has to be done. They have their advocacy groups. They’re long-established. There are also people out there who are far more interested in bikes — and eBikes — than I ever will be. They are set. Governments hear them. People also know what a bicycle is and most have ridden one.

Second, I have to show what is not Alt-Wheels:

Anything car-like, even if it’s being marketed as a “bike.” (Talk about stretching the category!)

This also isn’t Alt-Wheels:

Although called an eBike, it can be used throttle-only, which really makes it a type of lightweight sit-down scooter, ala Vespa.

These are the things I classify as Alt-Wheels:

Electric skateboards (eSk8):

Stand-up electric scooters (eScooters):

Electric unicycles (EUC):

The Onewheel:

Their common denominators:

– Made for a single rider
– Smaller than bicycles
– Easily affordable

Being portable has some caveats:

A high-end eSkateboard can hit 50 pounds.
The Boosted Rev eScooter is 46 pounds.
A high-end EUC can hit 60 pounds.

However, even with those extreme weights, they can all be trolleyed or wheeled.

And those are the upper limits of weight (such weight is due to batteries, not materials). That’s far, far below the upper limit of weight for micromobility!

The lowest weight limits for eSkateboards is about 10 pounds (but you really wouldn’t want to ride it); for eScooters about 15 pounds (again, not something you’d want); and for EUCs about 20 pounds (which is good for some people).

Maybe I should have called all this “Nano-Wheels.” Or — but this would be spiteful — “Alt-Mobility.”

But I’m sticking with Alt-Wheels.

Despite all the advocacy for bikes, I will repeat this: Not everyone can pedal and not everyone wants to pedal. And despite eBike sales booming in Europe, that’s not to say the same thing will happen here. eBikes are expensive, they’re heavy, and they’re large. Bike theft is rampant and until the issue of pervasive secure storage (“parking”) is addressed, their sales will be limited by the “What do I do with it when I arrive?” question.

And while that’s a question with Alt-Wheels too, at least when it comes to smaller and lighter eSkateboards, EUCs, and the Onewheel, their small size and portability generally means they don’t have to be left outside as magnets for thieves and vandals. They can be kept with you.

Plus, I’m correct in my advocacy. I saw in 1981 that we’d all be online. And here we are.

It will be generally the same way with Alt-Wheels. Their popularity is due to expand greatly. They are not for everyone — but they will be for millions. It won’t be unusual to see people riding them. They’re already being used for commuting.

This is the fringe of transportation. This is where the action really is.

Steve Jobs: Look At The Fringe

Good luck with micromobility, Horace and his team. My stand is here. At the fringe.

Previously here:

Alt-Wheels Sidebar: The China Factor
Alt-Wheels Notes category

This entry was posted in Alt-Wheels Notes. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.